Written by 5:03 am Cleaning Products

Plunger vs. Toilet Auger

An image showcasing two main tools for plumbing issues - a plunger and a toilet auger - side by side with no signs of brand names or logos. Both of the tools are lying on a neutral surface. The plunger has a wooden handle and a red rubber suction cup. The toilet auger features a crank handle and a coiled metal snake. Their shapes and distinctive features are highlighted for easy recognition. The backdrop of the image is a clean, unfettered white wall. The image does not contain any text, people or other objects.

Understanding Clogged Toilets and Your Best Solutions

Confronted with a clogged toilet, you might feel a tad bit overwhelmed.

Everyone has been there, and it’s crucial to have the right tools for unclogging.

Exploring the Classic Plunger

The plunger is often the first line of defense against a clogged toilet.

Its simple design and ease of use make it a must-have in every household.

Let’s talk specifics, shall we?

The standard plunger consists of a rubber cup attached to a handle.

When selecting a plunger, one should opt for a flange plunger rather than a cup plunger.

The flange plunger’s shape provides a better seal and suction for toilet clogs.

In use, the plunger works by creating a vacuum seal over the toilet drain.

Pumping the plunger forcefully drives water to dislodge the clog in the pipe.

Pros of a plunger include its affordability and the absence of any mechanical parts.

Cons are that it sometimes can’t handle more stubborn clogs or those further down the drain line.


  • Cost-effective and widely available
  • Easy to use, requires no special skills
  • Non-damaging to toilet


  • Might not work for tough clogs deep within the pipes
  • Can be messy if not used properly
  • Limited to certain types of clogs

When to Opt for a Toilet Auger

If the plunger fails, the next step up is a toilet auger, sometimes called a closet auger.

This tool is designed specifically for toilets and can reach deeper into the drain.

The toilet auger features a flexible cable with a crank handle.

The auger’s cable snakes down the toilet, twists, and breaks up the clog or hooks it to pull out.

More expensive than plungers, toilet augers are an investment and require a bit more finesse to operate.

However, they provide a stronger action against stubborn clogs that a plunger might not touch.

Pros of a toilet auger are its effectiveness in removing difficult clogs and safe use without scratching the toilet.

Cons include a higher price point and increased complexity in usage.


  • Highly effective for stubborn clogs
  • Reaches deeper into the toilet drain
  • Safe for toilets, designed to prevent scratching


  • More expensive than a plunger
  • Can be harder to use
  • Bulkier to store

Understanding the Mechanics of a Toilet Auger

Our journey with the toilet auger begins by appreciating its ingenious mechanism.

Essentially, it is a hand-cranked device with a long, flexible shaft made to navigate the curves of your toilet’s plumbing.

At the front of the auger, you’ll find a corkscrew-like tip that grasps and breaks up clogs.

The handle allows you to extend and retract the cable, giving you control as you tackle blockages.

For those tricky clogs that are out of reach for the average plunger, a toilet auger can be a game-changer.

Its reach and power can extract objects or build-up that would otherwise call for a plumber.

Now, you might be eyeing the market for a reliable toilet auger, and a popular choice is the RIDGID 59787 K-3 Toilet Auger.

Boasting a vinyl guard to protect your porcelain, it’s an example of a product that melds efficiency with safety.

Users often laud the K-3 for its robust construction and ease of use, characteristics that ring true across many reviews.

Most find that it handles common household clogs with ease, proving its worth time and again.


  • Durable, kink-resistant construction
  • Protective vinyl guard for the toilet bowl
  • Easy to maneuver into and around pipes


  • Some users report difficulty with extremely tough blockages
  • May require some physical strength to operate effectively
  • The initial cost is higher than basic tools

Find This and More on Amazon

Shop Now

Do-It-Yourself or Call the Professionals

Understanding when to pick up the plunger or auger and when to dial the plumber is crucial.

Not every clog situation requires professional intervention, but neither can every blockage be resolved with DIY efforts.

If you are facing frequent clogs or recurrent plumbing issues, it may suggest a deeper underlying problem.

While a plunger can quickly solve a minor blockage, repeated use for the same toilet could indicate it’s time to call in the experts.

A toilet auger is adept at handling clogs caused by typical household waste and small objects.

For issues further down the line or involving more complex plumbing systems, a plumber’s expertise may be warranted.

Cost is also a deciding factor; if you’re routinely spending on plumbing services, investing in a reliable auger might be more economical in the long run.

On the contrary, an occasional call to a plumber could be more feasible for someone who encounters blockages infrequently.

Maintaining Your Toilet Unclogging Tools

For your tools to last, proper care is a must.

A well-maintained plunger and toilet auger will serve you reliably when the need arises.

After use, always clean your plunger and auger thoroughly with a disinfectant.

Make sure they are dried out completely before storing to prevent rust or mold.

For plungers, inspect the rubber cup for cracks or degradation which can affect the suction.

Repeated exposure to harsh chemicals can speed up the wear and tear process, so keep an eye out.

Augers, with their mechanical nature, may need occasional lubrication to keep the crank mechanism smooth.

Also, watch for any bends or breaks in the cable which could impede its functionality.

Maintaining these tools not only prolongs their life but also ensures efficiency for when you are faced with the next clog.

Treating your tools right means they’ll be ready to bail you out of a messy situation, time and time again.

Comparison in Action: Plunger and Toilet Auger

Imagine you are facing a clog and weighing which tool to reach for from your arsenal.

Your choice between a plunger and a toilet auger will likely depend on the severity and depth of the clog.

For a standard, shallow clog created by toilet paper or organic waste, your trusty plunger might be all you need.

On the flip side, for something more substantial, like a child’s toy stuck in the toilet, an auger would be the superior option.

It’s also worth considering the physical effort needed for each tool. Plunging can be vigorous but straightforward.

Augering, while more technically demanding, is less about brute force and more about precision and technique.

Users who have faced both small and challenging clogs often have stories that attest to the necessity of both tools.

From minor blockages easily dispatched by a plunger to the dreaded depths that only an auger can reach, your bathroom toolkit should ideally contain both.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Unclogging Toilets

When it comes to unclogging toilets, a bit of knowledge can prevent potentially messy mistakes.

One common error is using too much force with a plunger, which can lead to water splashing everywhere.

With toilet augers, an often-made mistake is failing to secure the cable as it extends into the drain.

This can result in damage to the toilet or the tool, as well as an ineffective clog removal.

Another error is overestimating the capabilities of your tools.

Not all clogs are suitable for amateur efforts and recognizing this can save you a lot of trouble.

Finally, forgetting to wear appropriate protective gear like gloves can leave you with an unsanitary situation.

Always prioritize your health and safety over the urgency of clearing a clog.

Understanding When to Upgrade Your Tools

Just like any other tools, plungers and augers can wear out and may need to be replaced over time.

Deterioration can render these tools less effective, and a fresh replacement can be the difference between a quick fix and a prolonged problem.

You might consider an upgrade when you notice physical wear or if you’re finding your tool increasingly ineffective.

Frequent clogs might also justify investing in a higher-end model or thinking about a multi-pronged approach to your plumbing toolkit.

Reviews and user experiences are helpful to consult when considering a new purchase.

The OXO Good Grips Hideaway Toilet Plunger and Canister stand out for their combination of functionality and discreet storage.

Users appreciate the plunger’s effectiveness on most clogs and praise its storage canister for keeping things tidy.

This model marries practicality with pleasant aesthetics, something not always considered with such utilitarian tools.


  • Effective on a variety of clogs
  • Includes a convenient and discreet canister
  • The plunger design complements modern bathrooms


  • May not be as powerful as larger, traditional plungers
  • The canister, while sleek, can be difficult to clean
  • Higher price point than basic plungers

Find This and More on Amazon

Shop Now

Eco-Friendly Clog Removal

For environmentally conscious individuals, considering the eco-friendliness of your unclogging methods is important.

Both plungers and augers are more eco-friendly than chemical drain cleaners, which can harm plumbing and the environment.

A plunger requires no chemicals and simply uses the power of water and air pressure to dislodge clogs.

This method is completely non-toxic and safe for the ecosystem in your plumbing system.

A toilet auger also foregoes harsh chemicals and instead relies on mechanical action to clear clogs.

Making use of these tools not only protects your home and local environment but also often proves more effective and cost-efficient.

Close Search Window